The Swedish tiara I would give to someone who wants to learn to look at royal jewellery has four rather conspicuous gaps. Follow its outline from one end to the other and instead of a continuous line of diamonds you will find four large rosettes set upright, each given room to stand on its own. They look like components of something. They are. The surprise is when you find out how far apart in time the components and their present arrangement can be.
When I contributed to a feature on Sweden’s royal jewels, the Four Button Tiara made a useful comparison with the grander pieces that tend to turn up first in people’s minds. Its construction is extraordinarily clear from photographs. You can see the repeated ornaments and the frame supporting them as two separate ideas. For a collector, that makes it a particularly good exercise in dating an object.
Did you know? The buttons are older than the tiara
The Swedish encyclopaedia Nationalencyklopedin identifies the present tiara as a 1959 construction using four brilliant-cut diamond rosettes that had belonged to Karl XIV Johan. The rosettes were mounted on a silver frame. The source also distinguishes it from a similar piece with six rosettes. If you come across a picture captioned as the Button Tiara, start by counting the ornaments. It seems obvious when they’re laid out in front of you. It makes a great difference when you are following half a dozen photographs from different decades.
The reference to the rosettes’ earlier use makes the case even more interesting. Nationalencyklopedin records that the buttons were mounted for a time on Erik XIV’s crown on Karl XIV Johan’s initiative. That does not establish that the diamond ornaments were made in the sixteenth century, when the crown was made. The age of the crown, the period in which it carried the buttons and the date of the tiara describe different events. Write them on separate lines and the whole story becomes much easier to follow.
Look at the space around the clusters
On a broad high tiara I tend to look for the greatest weight or highest ornament in the middle. With the four rosettes it is more rewarding to see what would happen if they were moved a little closer together. There is enough space to read each flower from a distance. In photographs the arrangement changes noticeably according to the height at which it is worn and what the hair does behind it. That is the work of the mount as much as of the little flowers.
The court’s official description of the 2012 Nobel Prize ceremony says Crown Princess Victoria wore the Four Button Tiara with a brilliant-cut diamond row. Look at that photograph if you can. The extra line changes the geometry around the separate rosettes. If you compare photographs taken on different occasions, read the styling notes before assuming that what you see is an alteration made in the workshop. Wearing a jewel in a different arrangement can tell the next viewer a different story without changing the age of the main design.
What I’d look for on a much smaller jewel
The same questions come up when I turn over an antique brooch. Look at the contact points between the ornament and its support. Are there signs of an earlier fitting? Do the screws or joints repeat in a way that suggests several pieces were made to be handled separately? A trace of earlier work might matter a great deal. To know whether something was once a button, a pendant or the head of a pin, I’d want to see comparable objects and look for evidence of size, finish and attachment. The fact that it appears plausible from the front merely gives me a place to begin.
I enjoy the Four Button Tiara because the older ornaments remain so legible. In 1959 somebody gave those four little pieces a new relationship to each other and a new job to do. Look at a photograph for long enough and you can appreciate both the work that made each rosette and the different work that made them into a tiara.
Nationalencyklopedin on the Four Button and Six Button tiaras. The Swedish Royal Court’s 2012 Nobel Prize account. The Swedish royal jewellery feature I contributed to.
Leave a comment